Judith Butler on Gender Trouble, Sex and Identity - 717 Words

In order to do someone Justice we must take the subject out of subjectivity. In Judith Butlers gender/sex/desired gender trouble, identities are defined as subjects created through discourse and have no axiomatic definition. Butler attempts to show the reader that identities formed to gender and sex are singular forms of linguistic categories that are subjective to change. Gender for instance, rephrase to the socially constructed characteristics of masculinity and femininity. Inasmuch as identity is assumed to the stabilizing concept of sex, gender, and sexuality, the very notion of the person is called into question by the cultural emergence of those incoherent or discontinuous gendered beings hope youre to be persons but failed to conform to the gendered norms of cultural intelligibility by which persons are defined. The point here that butler wants us to understand is that as society constructs these subjects that individuals come to represent them and then challenges us to see ho w these descriptions come from a heterosexual normative that would not work in queer spaces where one can be identified as biologically neither male or female. For Butler performative femininity and masculinity are defined to hetero normative sexuality that ratifies it as the natural, while putting/keeping that normative subjects in a powerless or an important position in society. Butler argues that whether traditional or not we all perform a gender identity, and we must get past questioningShow MoreRelatedAnalysis Of Gender Trouble By Judith Butler1710 Words   |  7 Pages Judith Butler’s book; Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity explains everything from sex versus gender to feminist identity. Not only does Butler add on her own beliefs and thoughts but also considering work of another theorist such as Simone de Beauvoir and Luce Irigaray. Judith mainly focuses on Simeone de Beauvoirs novel â€Å"The Second Sex† and â€Å"Speculum of the Ot her Woman†. Judith’s Butler’s main question throughout her novel is; â€Å"Are we assigned our gender at birth orRead MoreA Brief Look at Judith Butler831 Words   |  3 PagesJudith Butler questions the belief that behaviors of either sex are natural. She proposes a rather radical theory that gender is performative and that sex is constructed. When gender is being performed, it means that someone would take on a role, acting in such a way that gives society the idea of their gender and constructs part of their identity. To be performative means that we produce a series of effects.Gender is constructed and is not in any way connected ‘naturally’ to sex. Nobody is bornRead MoreReflective Assessment : Being That I Am A Sociology Major1470 Words   |  6 Pagesat Kingston University is discussing sex and gender because gender is relational; it concerns both women and men. Primarily, I will discuss Judith Butlers ‘performativity’ and explain how females and males gendered roles are performed naturally. Furthermore, Simone de Beauvoir’s novel, The Second Sex hugely became an influential book, which involves sexuality, family, workplace, and reproductive rights and she distinguishes sex and gender and states that gender is gradually acquired. Lastly, I willRead MoreThe Social Construction Of Black Female Sexuality1411 Words   |  6 Pagesthe many social phenomena’s I have been interested in during my time at Kingston University is discussing sex and gender. Primarily, Judith Butlers ‘performativity’ explains how ‘females’ and ‘males’ gendered roles are performed naturall y through a routinely stylized behavior and how gender exist only because it is being acted out and performed. Furthermore, Simone de Beauvoir’s, The Second Sex hugely became an influential book during the second wave feminism, which involved sexuality, family, workplaceRead MoreGender and Postmodern1508 Words   |  7 Pagesargumentative essay on ‘Gender’ through comparison and contrast of the views of authorities who are postmodern practitioners† Introduction Defining postmodernism as well as gender is an extremely difficult task if not impossible. This essay is an argument on the two postmodernist’s concept on ‘Gender’. This essay argues posing foucauldian postmodernism of Judith Butler against Baudrillardean post modernism of Arthur and Marilouse Kroker with analysis on both their ideas on gender including sex and sexualityRead MoreEssay on Judith Butler and Postmodern Feminism2618 Words   |  11 PagesJudith Butler and Postmodern Feminism What necessary tasks does Judith Butler identify for feminist criticism? How is her articulation of and response to these tasks characteristically postmodern? She has no identity except as a wife and mother. She does not know who she is herself. She waits all day for her husband to come home at night to make her feel alive. This sentiment lay buried, unspoken, for many years, in the minds of American women, until In 1960, the problem that hasRead MoreAnalysis Of Judith Butler s S Gender Trouble2691 Words   |  11 Pagessocial abjection . In Judith Butler’s Gender Trouble, she identifies a need for a new interpretation of gender against the previous regime of ‘gender hierarchy and compulsory heterosexuality.’ In this essay, I will argue that Judith Butler’s approach to gender politics is an improvement on previous attitudes towards homophobia. I will do this through a close contextual reading of Butler’s work, particularly Gender Trouble and her article Imitation and Gender Insubordination. Butler calls for a more fluidRead MoreSigmund Freud Commentary On Psychology1529 Words   |  7 Pagesof evidence for these claims, as well as his tendency to brush off any data that proved him otherwise as irrelevant, means these claims are unsubstantiated and not reliable at best. Judith Butler Commentary In this extensive essay, Butler delves into the concept of gender constitution and the idea of performative acts. She poses the question that maybe humans should not be taken at face value or the value of their physical or biological self, as they are merely performingRead MoreGender Faced By Judith Butler1620 Words   |  7 PagesWhat is gender marking according to Judith Butler, (From Undoing Gender) and how can this theory be applied to constructions to racial identity in the Western world? According to Judith Butler’s 1990 book Gender Trouble, presented a new concept for looking a t sex and gender. As contrary to the fixed masculine and feminine gender binary, Butler insisted that gender need be perceived as fluid, variable; the aspect of people’s behavior at various times instead of who individuals are. Butler proposedRead MoreDoes Mulan Overthrow Oppressive Gender Norms?1308 Words   |  6 PagesMulan overthrow oppressive gender norms? In 1990, a novel was written by philosopher Judith Butler titled Gender Trouble. The importance of this novel was evident as it was a very controversial yet interesting analysis of the way we humans look at the topic of gender and sex. She explains throughout the book that our gender norms have been created by our ancestors and society. To many, crossing this boundary set by society is very deviant. Eight years after Gender Trouble was written, Disney released